Not so much directed at you specifically, but this is just touching on a pet peeve of mine. The pendulum has swung way too far to the other end, and rather than overreact to small samples, we statheads refuse to accept that it's normal for players to have sudden changes in ability. We've got 250-350+ PAs of fresh data on these guys, and that means something. There was always a non-zero collapse rate on guys like Soriano, and now that we've seen him collapse for 356 PAs going into today, we should be upping that rate pretty substantially. I'm not saying that it's impossible for him to have dropped off for good...but it would be a pretty remarkable thing if he did that (relatively) suddenly and that dramatically, especially after the start he got off to.