We're not talking about a 2% chance. And we're also not talking about "diving" into the wall. We're talking about running back fullspeed, gaining body control, leaping to catch the ball, and bracing for impact. OFs do that routinely (or at least attempt it). Soriano attempts it almost never. Heck he flunks the running fullspeed part most of the time, even when there's no wall in the equation. Yes, because he's not good at managing the wall, we've already established that. I have no idea why you'd want someone like that trying what you just described. You want him to "routinely attempt" something he's terrible at? Seems weird. I want him to routinely attempt to try his hardest to catch anything hit in his direction. Instead what I see is a guy that gives up quickly and is content to trot after the ball and pick it up when it stops rolling. Then your expectations are absurd. Why you would want a player with glaring OF weakness attempting whenever possible basically the most difficult thing an OF can do makes absolutely no sense to me. It would be one thing if Soriano was this talented defensive whiz who was just lazy, but he's not. "Trying hard" isn't automatically a good thing if it means trying for jumping and diving catches means you're giving up unnecessary doubles and triples. I mean, your argument is essentially "hey, guy who isn't a very good OF...I want you to be regularly BETTER than most OF by routinely attempting things that most guys actually don't routinely attempt (even though I'm convinced they do) and that are almost always beyond the realm of your defensive ability."