Neifi. You go back and look, and the defensive metrics really did like him and his WAR says he may not have been as bad as we thought. Nah, I don't need to ruin my outlook of him. I'm comfortable with it. I figured Neifi would be a better choice though. Yeah, picking Neifi is going to be based on his defense; his reputation for awfulness then and now was justifiably based out of his wretched offense, and there's no revisionist history going on there. It still sucks when you look back.