I think that's a little crazy considering LeBron is playing great defense right now, and Dirk, for all his awesomeness, has his issues on the defensive end. And offensively, Dirk has been absolutely amazing, but LeBron has quietly been pretty damn good too. Not as much as Dirk but the difference isn't enough to overcome Dirk's D No doubt you're right about the defense. But I don't think you overvalue the trait of being able to carry the team offensively when everyone knows you're going to be the one to score. Only a handful of players in history could do that, and LeBron isn't one of them. That's just ridiculous. LeBron is clutch time after time after time. He has improved his jumper dramatically. He had a few issues early in his career "closing games," and the entire Heat team decided to miss every late-game shot for about the first half of the season, but all of that has been way, way overblown. While we watch guys like Kobe take double-teamed, contested 3 pointers that brick and continue to give him (them) a pass, LeBron making the right basketball move or taking a guy one on one still has the meaningless tag of not being a "closer." It's ridiculous. LeBron is the number one guy in the NBA who I would want to have the ball with the game on the line.