Who specifically are you talking about? Barney, DeWitt, Baker, Lemahieu? If you want a good hitting 2B, you actually need a pretty good hitter. It's a productive position nowadays. They Cubs have been plugging holes at 2B for a while now and they have only on occasion filled it with actual production. Any of those guys, a platoon, Flaherty, etc. The Cubs have done a pretty decent job producing average-ish middle infielders . . . not so much at all with the corner positions/power hitters/outfielders. That's a big reason I'd look to spend money away from the middle infield. As for second base being productive, I'm not really seeing it. As you said, Barney has been crappy for awhile now, but he's still seventh in the NL in OPS among qualified second basemen. The third-highest is Freddy Sanchez, at merely .730. Among non-qualified second basemen, Barney is still thirteenth out of 37 -- and Baker is fifth. Only four players have OPS's above .800, and one of those only has 16 at bats (Chris Valaika). Seems to me that most second basemen are pretty fungible.