No, no it's not. Sure is. Cutler doesn't have a contract and his health is a question. If we're talking who is the better bet to win games for the remainder of THIS season, it's a fair debate. McCown has about 60% of the attempts Cutler has had and has been appreciably better. This debate assumes Cutler's health and his contract status after the season isn't an issue for this season. Those assumptions are dumb. Do you REALLY think Cutler is 100% for the rest of the year whether he plays or not?