Yeah, AJ is an American only by virtue of the fact his family happened to be in Alabama when he was born. When his father's contract ended, they went back to Iceland. He then spent 1 year of high school in FL later, graduating there, before going back to Iceland. So at least he spent some time here culturally. Green was born in Tampa, but similarly hasn't spent a lot of time in the states. He has a parent that's an American citizen, though, so culturally he's got that going for him. Chandler and Johnson both have similar stories, except that they were born in Germany and they have American fathers. Neither has spent any real time stateside. Jones actually has a house here, if I recall correctly. One final example of how the current rule could be applied in a sketchy way would be Brede Hangeland, who happened to be born in Houston to Norwegian citizens working for an oil company and left the country right after he turned 1, and never spent any time living here other than that. He could have, however, chosen to play for the US as he's technically a citizen by birth. One way the current rule hurts potential players would be the case of Diego Fagundez, who came here when he was 3, and has spent his entire life after that living in New England, but because his parents never became permanent citizens, his citizenship process would take 4 years or so. Ditto Nagbe. Both of those guy are more "American" than Johannsson culturally, and less American technically since both Fagundez's parents are Uruguayan. Yet neither guy is eligible at this point to play for the US despite being fully developed here, and having lived here for 15+ years. None of these guys can reasonably be credited to the US development system; they're all products of European youth/cliub development. Preston Zimmerman's idiot xenophobia aside, there's a very good debate somewhere in there as to whether or not the rule as-is should be altered.