I thought his giveaway for goal #3 was much worse. In fact, I figured that Ballack was Olsen's man for goal#4. I forgot we even had a back line after the 2nd goal. It looked like a complete breakdown, from the mids not being able to control pace to the back 4 not marking anyone. And for all the propers being thrown at Cory Gibbs for supposedly playing well despite being out of position, well...it's not rocket science, nor even rocket sauce. You don't get caught upfield and in the center when you're the right back. If Germany didn't suck, they'd have scored 7 with all the opportunities they had flying down a wing uncontested. And this isn't a new problem. It's a problem going back to the earliest parts of CONCACAF qualifying. Our defense is a huge question mark. Gooch is nails, but after him, you have Cherundolo, who's a nice player, and then what? Pope? I don't trust him to be anything but Jeff Agoos 2002 redux. Gibbs? If he gets back into shape, maybe, but until then, i dunno. Mastroeni is tenacious, but is he a 90 minute player? Hejduk scares me to death-if I were Keller I'd pray that he's not a starter. Too many stupid touches and giveaways more than outweigh his hustle. Eddie Lewis is going to end up being one of our defenders when all is said and done, which hurts the midfield. Then, our midfield has issues, too. Reyna's hurt again. Beasley has been poor as you noted. O'Brien will be lucky to be on the roster. Dempsey is good, but he can't go getting into fights with his team captain if he expects to start on the right side. Convey has guts, but is he a top-flight player? Zavagnin sucks. Conrad sucks. Olson sucks. Ralston is okay, but again, is he a top flight player? Noonan isn't good enough. And then up front, who scores? Watching the highlight montage from the Germany game in 2002 brought back the memories of how Donovan should have scored at least twice in that game's first half. He's not a great finisher-he's a setup guy. Upon my re-watching the game, Johnson looked worse than he did when I watched live. Unless he finds his previous form, he's almost a liability out there. McBride is getting long in the tooth. I like Twellman, but again, he's not top flight. Then you have Wolff, who's worse than Donovan at finishing, although he gets himself into position to score a lot, and Ching, who won't make the roster. I'm becoming much less optimistic at our chances. I need to see the entire team rounding into form soon, and not against scrub teams like Jamaica. Reyna has to stop going to the Cubs' trainers and keep himself on the field, because as much as I don't like him, he's invaluable to our midfield. *EDIT* I think Convey would get knocked around in the center of the field. He's a little undersized to be winnning 50/50 balls in the air. The fact that he's pretty strong on the ball, sort of fast, and not afraid to make runs at people would make him, for me anyway, the next-in-line choice for the right mid spot if Dempsey goes completely Artest and doesn't start. In fact, Demspey would make a better central AM than Convey. Klein is terrible. There's a giant gap between the MLS players and the guys with international experience. Our MLS guys could qualify in CONCACAF, but any good team they'd go up against would destroy them. The league is a lot better than what it was last WC cycle, but it's going to take anoth 10 years-at least-before we could hope to field a competent squad of MLS players in a European enviroment. I think what Arena will have to do is ditch the 4-4-2 and find a better formation that maximizes Donovan's strengths while hiding his weaknesses as much as possible.