Jeter and its not particularly close. Just look at the RC. It's almost laughable. Jeter is 34, appears to be on the decline, and is making $21M a year. There is just about no player I would take him over with that salary. Who said anything about salary. Jeter's decline and Theriot's incline will never meet. It's almost a joke of a question. I really don't understand the level of Jeter hate on this board. Just look at his numbers. I've never hated Jeter. I recognize him as a terrific offensive player. however, he's declining and will continue to decline and his defense is borderline terrible. Theriot will never match Jeter's offensive numbers but over the next few years will provide better defense and the money allows for more important upgrades to the team. the question might as well be Sabathia + Theriot or Jeter when salary is considered.