Wait, Hurdle is to blame for playing all of his players? I watched most of the game and I could have sworn that Buck said Francona only had 1 player left on his bench in about the 6th or 7th. So the managers managed the same way (to get everyone into the game). The AL is just deeper than the NL, when it comes to talent. The starters for each league are pretty evenly matched. But the AL bench was far superior to the NL bench, if you ask me (sizemore, Longoria, Morneau, Kinsler). And the RPs are much better (Nathan, Paps, KRod, Rivera in consecutive innings - holy crap). Yes. Hurdle is to blame for this entire mess. Well, it's Selig's mess to begin with, but it's Hurdle's fault we lost. Isn't he the one who pick's his pitching staff? How can you honestly pick a pitching staff and not have Johan Santana and Jake Peavy on the roster? I don't care what their records are or what their other significant stats are, these are absolutely 2 of the best pitchers in the NL, and I'd much rather have these guys with a game on the line than Aaron Cook or Brad Lidge or even Carlos Marmol right now. This is no longer about getting every player in the game. This is about home field advantage, as stupid as that may sound. I will applaud the first manager who says "screw playing time, I want to win this game". Ah, but the good ole boy network probably doesn't have a single manager who has the nads to buck the system. This will forever stay one of the dumbest things Bud Selig did under his legacy of doing dumb things. The pitching staff held the AL to 4 runs in 15 innings and didn't exactly have stellar defense behind them. I also can't believe anyone really expects a manager to play starters for 8 innings. I don't care if the game "counts" all those guys want to play. But most of the starters only want to play 3-4 innings anyway. It's not the old boys club that's stopping the manager from playing starters the entire game. It's wanting to please 30 guys that all want to play. Sounds like little league, but that's the overriding influence. I think it's BS to blame a manager for losing an ASG. He's put into a BS situation by Selig and he's trying to please a bunch of people. And of course he took Aaron Cook. Same reason the ASG was full of Yankees for about 10 years. To the "victor" goes the spoils. How many ASGs do you think Hurdle expects to manage? Making an exhibition "count" by basing HFA in the championship series on the winner is stupid.