I'll preface this post by saying I think Colvin is probably a lot better than he's shown this season. Not as good as the player we saw last year, but better than he's been this year. He's currently got a line of .113/.191/.258. The positive thing is, a .78 IsoD (isolated discipline, the difference between his average and OBP) and a .145 IsoP (isolated power, the difference between his average and slugging) aren't terrible numbers. However, Colvin isn't just hitting into bad luck to this point. His BABIP is .161, and while you'd think that was due to go up, he's simply not hitting line drives right now either (11.1 LD%). His LD% has gone up recently, but only slightly. Before he gets at all productive again, Colvin's going to have to start hitting the ball harder. And as long as the three starting OFs are highly productive, you can't throw an offensive black hole out there. As for sending Colvin down, I just don't know that it would help much. He might get a little more confidence hitting AAA pitching, but his ceiling is probably as a 4th OF and that's his current role. i don't necessarily disagree with any of your points. However, with his current inability to do much of anything and Quade's complete lack of confidence in him, more ABs at the AAA level might be what he needs. Otherwise, he's not a 4th OF, he's a waste of a roster spot. I haven't checked and don't know that there's any better options available. But if getting more confidence hitting AAA pitching actually allows him to be a decent 4th OF at the ML level, then that's an option the Cubs should strongly consider.