Having had the surgery for both problems, I consider myself fairly knowledgeable on the subject. Up until about 3 years ago, a torn labrum had to be fixed in an open surgery as opposed to an arthroscopic procedure. Now, they can do it with the scope, resulting in far less scarring, pain, and rehab time. My doctor is in fact the same guy who did Morris' surgery and he is damn good. I can say that the amount of pain involved in throwing when there is a problem with the labrum is significant and it feels like your shoulder is on fire and about to explode after every throw (See John Smoltz in the playoffs a few years ago). All in all, I think they should shut him down, fix the shoulder and see what he can do next year. If it turns out anything like Morris di, I will be a happy camper.