I sure wouldn't. Because of his slightly higher OPS and higher OBP and other miscellaneous sabermetrics? I'm just a caveman; your flashing lights, zooming cars, and mathematics frighten and disorient me, but I think I'll go with the guy who had over 100 more bases that season. Would you have the guy who made 474 outs or the guy who made 382 outs. If the guy with 474 outs contributed more than the guy with 382, then I'd go with the former.