He was in the Top 5 in voting five different times. I just looked it up and Roy Oswalt also has five Top 5 finishes without a win as does Jack Morris. FWIW Zambrano did that three times. Andy Pettite had four Top 5 finishes. In my five minutes of messing around on B-R with all of this, the most Top 5 finishes without a win is Mike Mussina who had six. In my research it looks like Schilling has the most times as a runner up without a win at three times.