To be fair, Rafael Furcal was playing SS in Atlanta while DeRosa was there and Michael Young was playing SS while DeRosa was in Texas. Michael Young came up as a 2b, and Soriano moved Young to SS. It happens. But, because a better player is blocking you from playing a position for several years doesn't mean you can't play the position. 2008 will be the ultimate test. DeRosa is currently out of a starting gig if the Roberts deal is true. The only position he has even the slightest, remotest chance of winning the starting job is SS. And the competition, in my mind, won't be fierce since it will likely come down to one of Ryan Theriot, Mark DeRosa or Alex Cintron (once he's signed) :roll: DeRosa has a stronger arm than Theriot. It's debateable, but let's assume Theriot has a bit more range. Range probably converts to a few more outs than arm strength, so we can give Theriot a slight edge defensively at SS. That slight difference won't touch the difference between the two at the plate. And where does this team need the most help? At the plate? Yes. If the season begins today, the Cubs look to be one of the stronger defensive teams in the league. Because of the strength of that defense, I think you can sacrifice some of that defense for offense. And Theriot can still get some starts there when DeRosa is needed elsewhere or if DeRosa needs a day off. To spin this another way, the Cubs are paying Theriot league minimum to be a league minimum (offensive production) major league SS. DeRosa is getting paid 4m to be his back up? Something has to give. I think Lou showed last year that just because he gives a guy a chance, it doesn't mean he'll stick with him (see Izturis). If Theriot starts slow, I see Lou moving DeRosa to short full time.