Nobody is saying Lee has been terrible. You are just assuming because some of us don't think he's an All-Star that means we think he's terrible, and then using absolutely no statistical basis for your opinion. He should get better, but up to this point he in now way deserves All-Star consideration. He'll get it, but he doesn't deserve it, and he certainly deserves less consideration than Soto, Ramirez, Fukudome, Soriano (although injured), Zambrano, Dempster, Wood, Marmol, Theriot and DeRosa. There's a difference between bashing a player and showing that he isn't perfect, or the best in the league.