Every team that has tried to get cute with their rotation in the playoffs so far has suffered as a result. The Indians didn't discover a new market inefficiency last year, they just rode an incredible string of fortunate pitching until they ran out of gas midway through the World Series. So far this year: - The Yankees went with Severino with the plan to go bullpen game at the first sign of trouble, and Severino got a single out. - The Astros went with Verlander in relief with runners on up 2-1 in the series and Verlander promptly relinquished the lead. - The Red Sox went with Sale in relief and couldn't make it work. - The Indians decided to hole Kluber to Game 2 and pitch Bauer on short rest in Game 4, and got no success from either plan. - The Diamondbacks decided to piggy back starters for the WC game and Game 1, and they're basically out of pitching midway through game 3 and are about to get swept. The Dodgers, Cubs and Nationals have basically gone business as usual with the 1-4 starters, and they're both the most well rested staffs, and have pitched the best.