Well, I'd certainly call Szczur's production this year higher. An .800 OPS in the FSL with a .390 OBP is better value than an .830 in the PCL with a .340 OBP, and it really isn't that close. That's even taking into account the fact that one is a somewhat raw 22 year old in high A while the other one is 23 in AAA. Then you look at the other factors. Jackson definitely has a much better minor league track record before this year. Jackson also has the higher ceiling, although Sczcur is more likely to stick in CF. But I think I'd label Sczcur as the safer one to hit his ceiling at this point because of Jackson's strikeout issues and the fact that Sczcur is going to get more value out of his defense (which is more easily projectable than offense). While Sczcur is still 2 levels below which throws more uncertainty in, his BB/K ratio and his speed should make him less prone to numbers collapsing at a higher level than some other prospects. So I'd probably give it to Jackson, but I could see people putting Sczcur ahead because there are so few comparables to what Jackson is doing right now. While Sczcur has definitely taken some big steps foward as a prospect this year, if you put him ahead of Jackson that's more of an indictment of Jackson than anything IMO. Track record is the key for me. Jackson's Daytona numbers run circles around Szczur's. Granted they are completely different players (Jackson in a different class power-wise). And it's hard for me to say Szczur is a safer bet to hit his ceiling, because he has a couple levels to go before the majors. Jackson is a call-up away from the majors. His K rate wasn't that bad in the lower levels of the minors, and while it's not likely to be anything as disturbing as Brett is going thru right now, Szczur could very well have more trouble making contact when he faces more experienced pitchers.