It is a "bargain" because I do think he's the best player in the game. However, it wasn't a "hometown discount" like McGwire's. Pujols himself said, "No hometown discounts." And arbitration is a crapshoot. Yeah, he could've been awarded $20 million (although I don't think his agent would've asked for that, but you get my point) or he could've been awarded $6 million (a figure the Cards could have offered and would still be a nice raise over his 2004 salary). Neither side wanted to take a chance. But taking an average of $14 million is not a hometown discount. Pujols said "no hometown discount" because he was in bargaining mode, at the time. What do you think he was going to say? "Anything they want to offer me is fine"? He wanted to stay in St. Louis, but he's not braindead. Maybe it wasn't a hometown discount. Maybe Edmonds' relatively cheap salary isn't, either. Maybe Carpenter's isn't. Maybe Morris' isn't. Maybe Jocketty is just a genius. Either way is fine with me. Steve Kline is on record as saying that he wishes he had taken less money to play in St. Louis this year. That didn't go over well in Baltimore, but he said it, nontheless. Look, I'm not saying the Cardinals haven't had guys who publicly said they would take less money to play here. Heck, I live here, I know about Edmonds, McGwire and Rolen. But I just have to refute anyone (and I'm not necessarily saying you) who even pretends that type of stuff only happens to St. Louis. Need I remind you of Andre Dawson's blank check offer to the Cubs back in 1987? Anyway, for every Rolen there's a Renteria, who didn't want to accept less money. And don't forget Matt Morris turned down a lucrative offer from the Cardinals in 2004, but then got hurt so he had to sign the one year $2 million contract he now has. Had he not gotten hurt he wouldn't even be a Cardinal today. I think Carpenter took the best offer possible after coming off of surgery. Yes, Pujols could've said nothing just as he did even though he was grossly underpaid after the 2003 season when he got a raise from $900,000 to $3 million. Plus, he, I'm sure, was fully aware of guys who had said they'd take less to stay here. I doubt he would've accepted a 7/$65 million contract just because he wanted to stay in St. Louis. It's a bargain for the Cardinals but Pujols didn't give them a hometown discount. Whether they purposely took a discount or not, I don't think Carpenter and Pujols are good examples. They are both being paid less, and will be paid less next year than the open market would pay them. Rolen, on the other hand, has a lengthy contract and many years on his contract (and one career year). He is being overpaid this year, and he will most likely be overpaid next year.