His WAR was like half this year. He wasn't the same player. He played in only 75% of the games he did in 2010 because his face got exploded. The rest of the difference is made up by defensive stats. And before you try to argue he was that good defensively in 2010, here are his UZR values by year (since 2005): 5.3, 2.9, 2.3, 2.8, -8.1, 9.8, 2.2 Tell me, do you really think he was a 9.8 run defender in CF in 2010, or is it more likely we are looking at some of that famous UZR variance?