The question of Jones versus Pie is a "this year" or "next year" argument. There's no doubt this is a flawed team still. And it would take everything going right to take this team from last to first. The rest of the NL Central must falter, and our own team has to overcome a myriad of issues to allow us to win the division crown this season. Is it possible? Certainly. The NL Central is undeniably weak, and early returns on some of our more pressing issues have been promising. The team, and perhaps most notably Cesar Izturis, have been walking at a much improved rate from previous seasons. Our bullpen looks solid, and the starting pitchers have almost all been doing well. Personally, I lean towards keeping Jones and making a run at it this season. He can most likely be more useful this season than Pie. However, we are not historically lucky as Cubs fans. I understand the desire to go ahead and trade off Jones and give Pie a year to adjust to MLB pitching. If we are not in the position we think we are, and are more like the 2005 Mets, in being much improved after a big spending spree but still a year away, it would be folly to not hand the job over to Pie. If Jones and the team falter, we could always bring up Pie and play him in right through the rest of the season.