Jump to content
North Side Baseball

Rob

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    15,247

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    13

 Content Type 

Profiles

Joomla Posts 1

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospects Ranking

News

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

The Chicago Cubs Players Project

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Pick Tracker

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by Rob

  1. Rob
    Todd Walker, Michael Barrett and Mark DeRosa were all better players than Reed Johnson. DeRosa, yes, but he brought two other guys as well. Beyond that, you're splitting hairs. I get Johnson's BABIP is high, but the guy is having a great year, can play all 3 OF positions, and is cheap. Guys like that have value to contenders. Walker are Barrett had been legitimate starting caliber players for contending teams in previous years. Now they were both obviously on the downslopes of their careers, but there's still some degree of upside to guys who have shown more in the past (remember our Jim Edmonds acquisition?). Reed Johnson has never been perceived as a starting caliber player. Again, I'm not saying I don't see the value in Reed Johnson. I absolutely do see it. I just see that utility guys and 4th outfielders bring back less in trades than guys teams are planning to plug in as the starter.
  2. Rob
    Todd Walker, Michael Barrett and Mark DeRosa were all better players than Reed Johnson.
  3. Rob
    Are you just assuming the acquiring teams will ignore every other year of his career when evaluating him? I'm not suggesting that we're going to get Domonic Brown or Jesus Montero for him just that he's a very cheap 2 month rental for a team looking for a solid bat off the bench. it's 2 months and he'd be coming off the bench. you don't get "solid young high upside prospects" for that. Bingo. I'd love to trade Reed and think other teams should be legitimately interested in him. But I'd be shocked if we got much more than an Evan Crawford type for him... a mildly intriguing prospect with significant holes is a pretty reasonable price.
  4. Rob
    I saw an episode of The Shield with a similar situation, though it was a shipping container on the outskirts of town.
  5. Rob
    there is? he's 4th all time in defensive WAR, and in the top 100 for WAR for position players. http://www.fangraphs.com/graphsw.aspx?playerid2=1012186&playerid3=1013157&playerid4=335&playerid5= If you don't believe Trammell and Larkin belong in the Hall (and plenty don't), it's pretty easy to make the case Ozzie doesn't either... especially if you want to cast doubt on defensive metrics in general. Like I said, I'm a big hall guy and would have all of them in there. But there's a case.
  6. Rob
    I don't have a problem with him being in the Hall of Fame (I'm a big Hall guy, personally), but there is a legitimate argument to be made that Ozzie Smith doesn't belong in the Hall. And Lindstrom doesn't exactly stand up to the Hall of Fame 3B standard... though I would certainly agree that standard is way higher than it should be.
  7. Rob
    The Meche deal doesn't look so bad now.
  8. Rob
    That's certainly possible. But somebody should have been. Why? He's a platoon player with chronic back problems who isn't very good defensively anymore. Didn't say teams should be falling over themselves to acquire him. But he's a nice complementary piece. Hits lefties well and is fine defensively in the corners as well as able to handle CF (though to what degree is debatable). There are guys like that all over baseball. I mean, I get your point, but the likely reality is that nobody wanted him vs. the Cubs not trying to trade him. Someone like Baker I get because he's back next year. Johnson doesn't fit into the Cubs' plans at all, so I'm sure they would have been happy to give him up if anyone was offering anything. $5 says if Hendry is back next year, so is Reed Johnson. Something tells me somebody was willing to offer something small, but Hendry didn't want to trade him for that little since it might hurt his chances of bringing him back next year.
  9. Rob
    That's certainly possible. But somebody should have been. Why? He's a platoon player with chronic back problems who isn't very good defensively anymore. Didn't say teams should be falling over themselves to acquire him. But he's a nice complementary piece. Hits lefties well and is fine defensively in the corners as well as able to handle CF (though to what degree is debatable).
  10. Rob
    That's certainly possible. But somebody should have been.
  11. Rob
    In fairness to Hendry, this deadline doesn't mean all that much. The guys we all wanted moved are almost all paid enough money that nobody is going to just claim them on waivers... and if they do, that's probably a better deal than we would have gotten anyways. About the only guy we should have traded but may have trouble doing so now is Reed Johnson. That said, I'm very disappointed at our inactivity... and as much as I like Carlos Pena, he better not be our plan at 1B going forward.
  12. Rob
    hahahahahahahahahahaha
  13. Rob
    I'd be all about trying to snag Matt Bush. That strikeout rate is legit.
  14. Rob
    I keep seeing visions of Eric Patterson, sadly.
  15. Rob
    The average major league 2B this season has hit .255/.316/.379 Barney is at .300/.328/.369 In other words, because of Barney's lack of plate discipline and power, he's only managed to be an average 2B despite his .300 batting average. So yeah, it's possible to be a productive ML player... but you aren't going to find many stars without real secondary skills.
  16. Rob
    I absolutely refuse to label Samardzija as a bust until he's out of our system entirely... the way his peripherals absolutely refuse to stabilize from year to year, I wouldn't be any more shocked to see a K/9 of 13 next year with a BB/9 of 4, or the complete opposite. WILD CARD!
  17. Rob
    Castro would probably fit the bill. Of course, his development is almost the very definition of "special circumstances."
  18. Rob
    Actually, I didn't bother reading the posts you were quoting... or even the first sentence of your post.
  19. Rob
    Pretty much. The Cubs will be garbage for at least most of the next decade if they go that route. Really doesn't jive with how savvy the Ricketts are as businessmen/women. If Ricketts really wants Joe Cowleys prophecy to come true and have Chicago become the White Sox town, then he should definitely go this route. Nah, they're pretty screwed, too. Especially if Kenny is left in charge. I don't understand why people think Crane Kenney is doing a bad job. He's not here to be the baseball guy. He's basically head of marketing.
  20. Rob
    FWIW, I care less now about managers who love bunting, stealing, hit and runs, etc... than I did a few years ago. They're not as bad tactically in this lower offensive environment. That said, Bob makes me roll my eyes plenty when he acts when Soriano and Aramis are the problem spots on this team.
  21. Rob
    With the exception of this year, I have hated each and every Wilken draft... at least on draft day. A couple years later, they generally look a whole lot better... to the point that even I have to concede that he's probably an above average scouting director. Unless we're bringing in a particularly talented guy like Logan White to take over, I don't see a good reason to be rid of Wilken. Fleita on the other hand... I'm sad to say it since he does seem like a genuinely nice person, but it's time for him to go.
  22. Rob
    Goldstein on twitter:
  23. Rob
    I think some people need to let go of the disappointment of him being the #3 overall pick and just look at what he is. He's a young guy in an advanced league who is playing at an above-average level while showcasing an ability to put the ball in play. Does he have holes in his game? Yeah, but he seems pretty likely to reach the majors and provide at least some value for us. Bust as the #3 pick? Probably. Bust as a prospect? Certainly not yet.
  24. Rob
    That's a bit of a misrepresentation. People wanted him, but that was when they thought he'd be cheap and come on a one year deal. He was neither.
  25. Rob
    Thanks for posting that scouting report on Marcano, Raisin. Sounds like another interesting bat.
×
×
  • Create New...