Statistically, I don't think you can pick a clear winner. In peripherals, Pujols has Howard beat (although it is close), but in RBI's and HR's, Howard is ahead by a decent margin. BA: Pujols: .331 (3rd in the NL), Howard: .313 (8th in the NL) OBP%: Pujols: .431 (1st in the NL), Howard: .425 (4th in the NL) SLG%: Pujols: .671 (1st in the NL), Howard: .659 (2nd in the NL) HR's: Pujols 49 (2nd in the NL), Howard: 58 (1st in the NL) RBI's: Pujols 137 (2nd in the NL), Howard: 149 (1st in the NL) K's: Howard: 181 (2nd most in the NL), Pujols 50 (?) OPS: Pujols: 1.102 (1st in the ML), Howard: 1.084 Defensively, obviously the Gold Glove winner Pujols is better, but Howard is no slouch. An Pujols' did lead his team to the world series. I know Howard had the odds stacked up against him, but that is going to be a factor for writers who are voting. Whoever wins though, it won't be by alot, and will deserve to win it.