Jason Giambi, Alex Rodriguez, David Ortiz, Jack Cust, Brendan Donnelly, Gary Sheffield, Paul Byrd, Ivan Rodriguez, Andy Pettitte, Brian Roberts, Gary Matthews Jr, Jerry Hairston Jr, Rick Ankiel, Troy Glaus, Matt Williams, Jose Guillen, Magglio Ordonez, Mike Piazza, Ryan Franklin, Sergio Mitre, Manny Ramirez, Edinson Volquez along with a bunch of nobodies that nobody ever cared enough to have an opinion on pre or post-steroids No argument here, but I was referring to players who were all-time greats and who might otherwise be embraced as such by their respective franchises, have their numbers retired, etc. if not for the PED's issue. From your list I think that could include Pudge (Tex), Pettite (NYY), Piazza (NYM) and Manny (BoSox). Giambi and Sheff have great numbers but their prime years don't really "belong" to one franchise (especially Sheff). Ortiz is definitely a BoSox, and he's effectively been "forgiven" by being productive and popular in the "post steroid" era, so I'd be surprised if his number weren't retired by the Red Sox. ARod is interesting. He's had amazing years for all three franchises he's played for, but I think he's identified as a Yankee and has been embraced there. By the time his career is over he will have played at least ten (10) seasons for them, won at least one WS, and put up some enormous numbers. I think he has a good shot at having his number retired as well.