Is that so? His W-L was 3-5 in April/May 2005, his ERA was 3.71 (a 3.71 ERA would have been good enough to be in the top 20 starters in the NL in 2005) Through the end of May 2005 Pettitte allowed 26 ER in 63 IP Through the end of May 2006 Pettitte has allowed 45 ER in 71-2/3 IP If a 3.71 "wasn't very good", what exactly do you call a 5.65? BTW 1st half generally refers to pre ASB, Pettitte had a 6-7 record at the ASB break with an ERA of 3.09 NSBB is the only place where one can read a Cardianl fan evisorate the argument of an Astros fan on a Cubs board. This place is great. Thank you Tim. Sign of for Premium folks. What is so good about Premium, anyway?