Look at his minor league success. He was very, very, very good as a starter. sure, so was Pie. just saying that he's probably the best reliever in the game right now. no reason to rock that boat Exactly. If it isn't broken, don't fix it. one could argue the rotation is going to need some fixing at some point in the near future. One could also argue that Marmol is just as valuable coming out of the pen in a tight situation and slamming the door as he would be pitching every 5th day. Usually middle relievers can be replaced and shuffled around, but Marmol is an exception. How many jams has he gotten us out of this year? Every team in baseball would kill for a guy like Marmol. Why would we want to kill the golden goose?