cincy is very unlikely to make the playoffs and has a borderline ace (cueto) who is a free agent after this season. What is it about Cueto that you find to be "borderline" ace? what is the question, the borderline or the ace? Probably the part in quotes. He hasn't had an era above 3.00 since 2010 well, he only struck out 6 batters per 9 innings in 2011 and his FIP was like a run and a half above his actual ERA. his FIP has fallen into the low 3s and clearly last year was his best one - highest K rate and still low BB rate - but he still had the second-highest LOB% and the lowest BABIP in baseball. maybe he's one of those guys who can outpitch his peripherals consistently, but right now i'd probably slot him in around the top 20-25 starters, which is still really good. just not quite in the upper echelon of #1 starters (which would be the likes of kershaw, king felix, strasburg, sale, bumgarner, harvey, greinke, probably a couple of others).