ooh this looks fun. unlike MLB pre-1947, i'm gonna let the blacks play too. Starting five: Walter Johnson - R (773 PRAA, 3.37 DERA) Pedro Martinez - R (400 PRAA, 3.12 DERA) Lefty Grove - L (494 PRAA, 3.38 DERA) Pete Alexander - R (564 PRAA, 3.53 DERA) Cy Young - R (860 PRAA, 3.45 DERA) Bullpen Sandy Koufax - L (233 PRAA, 3.56 DERA) Tom Seaver - R (409 PRAA, 3.69 DERA) Roger Clemens - R (682 PRAA, 3.18 DERA) Satchel Paige - R (N/A) Steve Carlton - L (266 PRAA, 4.02 DERA) Mariano Rivera - R (399 PRAA, 2.29! DERA) Starting lineup: SS - Honus Wagner (career .311 EqA - weighed down by several "poor" years late in his career) LF - Ted Williams (.359) RF - Babe Ruth (.363) 1B - Lou Gehrig (.341) CF - Willie Mays (.330) C - Josh Gibson (N/A) 3B - Mike Schmidt (.314) 2B - Joe Morgan (.314) Reserves: C - Yogi Berra (.286) IF - Alex Rodriguez (.322) IF - Rogers Hornsby (.337) OF - Oscar Charleston (N/A) OF - Ty Cobb (.330) OF - Barry Bonds (.352) Toughest call was CF - Mays, Charleston, Cobb and Mantle (.342) are all worthy candidates of starting, and one of them had to be left off the team. It was also tough to leave off Musial (.332), Warren Spahn (281 PRAA, 4.02 DERA), Bob Gibson (312 PRAA, 3.75 DERA) and Greg Maddux (457 PRAA, 3.65 DERA). I also have a feeling that Jackie Robinson (.308) would've been really awesome if he'd been allowed to play in MLB through his 20s - look at his numbers, and those were put up after his peak.