Rank your top 10 catchers of all-time. I'll put in for your consideration the top 25 catchers from Bill James' top 100 rankings, which he uses win shares to rate, as well as any catchers who are in the HOF but did not make James' top 25 list. Consider only their major league numbers - i.e., for Roy Campanella, do not take into account his years in the Negro Leagues. Linked are the baseball-reference.com statistics for each player. Number 1 is to be the best all-time catcher, and so on. I'll mention this just once, but as is noted in James' book, it's important to understand the era during which players played. For this, take a look through the American League numbers from its inception. As is pretty evident, most of the 1900s and 1910s were part of a "dead ball" era in which pitchers dominated; then offense dominated in the 1920s and 1930s. Pitching was a little more effective during WWII, then the years from WWII to 1960 were pretty even between the pitchers and hitters. From 1963-1972, pitchers took over once again. Beginning in about 1986, pitching was overwhelmed by hitting. What does all this mean? James says that the natural tendancy is to compare one player's numbers to another's without understand the context. So, the most frequently screwed over players, in terms of making the HOF, are hitters who played in a pitchers' era or in a pitchers' park for much of their careers; or, pitchers who played during a hitters' era and pitched in a bandbox. To level the playing field, I encourage people to look at ERA+ and OPS+, as well as a player's ranking against his peers in various statistical categories. Johnny Bench Yogi Berra Bob Boone Roger Bresnahan Roy Campanella Gary Carter Mickey Cochrane Darren Daulton Bill Dickey Buck Ewing Rick Ferrell Carlton Fisk Bill Freehan Gabby Hartnett Elston Howard Ernie Lombardi Tim McCarver Thurman Munson Lance Parrish Mike Piazza (active) Darrell Porter Ivan Rodriguez (active) Ray Schalk Wally Schang Ted Simmons Gene Tenace Joe Torre