OK now my thoughts on your list: Pitchers: Kid Nichols belongs on there, even though I'm sure nobody knows who he is. Don Sutton has no business being on that list. Consider Bob Feller or Carl Hubbell. There are probably better options than Gaylord Perry too. Hitters: Manny Ramirez... is he better than Yaz and Shoeless Joe at this point? If so he belongs on the list. If not, he probably doesn't. Rafael Palmeiro, Todd Helton, Jim Thome, Vladimir Guerrero, Carlos Delgado shouldn't be on the list IMO. Neither should Winfield, Dawson, Brock. Stargell, Banks, Sheffield are borderline. The most glaring omissions, in order of James' rankings, are: 15. Joe Morgan 18. Eddie Collins 26. Rickey Henderson 30. George Brett 32. Jackie Robinson 33. Pete Rose 35. Craig Biggio 39. Arky Vaughan (seriously, look him up) 40. Nap Lajoie 41. Yogi Berra 44. Johnny Bench 50. Duke Snider 53. Roy Campanella 54. Tony Gwynn 55. Robin Yount 58. Ryne Sandberg 59. Charlie Gehringer 60. Wade Boggs