Carlos Lee's slugging % is 497 lifetime and has been around 540 the last couple of seasons. Berkman's is 557 lifetime and has cycled from a high of 621 last season to a 515 a few years ago. Berkman (switch hitter) is also more difficult to deal with b/c he bats left handed (most of the time)as opposed to the right handed Lee, so he has that advantage as well. As for last year, Phil Garner is a very very sneaky guy. A fellow Tennessean, he has the name Old Scrap Iron for a reason. He was hiding Berkman last season. He was continually changing his lineup, keeping a hot hitter behind Berkman. That way, you had to decide against pitching to Berkman vs. someone who was hot. Ensberg who backed him up until June was hitting .329 in the month of april and down eventually to 265 by the end of may. Garner then moved in Preston Wilson and dropped Berkman to the 4 hole. Then it was Huff and Lane for the rest of the year. Just about anyone who backed up Berkman, had a significant jump in their avg. immediately following the move. Altogether pretty sly. OPS behind berkman was just about the same, or slightly lower, last year than it is this year