Would you make this trade?

[TheVolCub08]

In one of my keeper leagues, I have a trade proposed to me that I am torn on. Team 2 is asking me for Player A and a 3rd round pick, and is offering Player B and a 2nd round pick and a higher 3rd round pick.

 

Player A is an All Star, former MVP who is coming off an injury, but who plays in a great hitters park in a great hitters lineup and who is just 27 years old. Because he is out of exemptions, he costs points to keep from year to year.

 

Player B is coming off a decent rookie season, was a good prospect, and plays in a weaker hitters lineup (but one that is young and could be getting better.) He is 2 years younger and will still have 2 exemptions remaining after this season. The overall projected point value from A to B is about 60 points (around 3 points per week.)

 

This deal would give me a guy I'd be able to keep around for at least 2 more years and would give me 6 of the top 38 picks. It would cost me probably the #3 guy at his position. Thoughts?