Cubs Video
Michael Busch didn't hit lefties badly at all in 2026; that wasn't the problem. In 204 plate appearances, the lefty batter hit .243/.348/.422 against southpaws, marking a big improvement from his more limited work against them in 2025. However, many of the adjustments Busch made (to his stance, to his contact point, and to his approach) to handle becoming an everyday player made him less effective against right-handed pitchers. He hit .272/.356/.554 against them in 2025; those numbers fell to .241/.354/.382 in 2026. Most of any batter's plate appearances come against righties, of course, so by losing so much against them, Busch suffered a huge net loss, despite his big progress against lefties.
If at all possible, the Cubs need to un-ring the bell in 2027. Busch should return to a modified platoon role, getting 550 or more plate appearances but far short of 700, with strict instructions to restore the setup and attack he utilized in 2025. That might prove a losing battle, and 2025 might end up looking like a career year for a player limited by his unimposing stature and below-average bat speed, but the team has to try it. To do so, though, they also need to find a reliable platoon partner for him.
The person they sign need not start against all lefties, and they need not be a pure first baseman. With Seiya Suzuki headed elsewhere via free agency, the team also has to backfill its designated hitter spot, and they've traded their top two bat-first prospects (Owen Caissie and Moisés Ballesteros) since the start of 2026. Here's a ranking of seven options to replace some of the production the team is losing in its corner outfield and DH spots, while also supporting Busch by releieving him of some responsibilities against lefties. We're going from most to least desirable.
- Jake Burger, Texas Rangers: Set to make roughly $7 million via arbitration this winter, Burger might become a luxury the cost-cutting Rangers prefer not to afford. He's about as unvarnished an opposite of Busch as you can find: right-handed, thickly built, with a very aggressive approach at the plate and plus-plus bat speed. However, he's also surprisingly nimble at first base and a good receiver of errant throws. He batted .228/.302/.421 in 2026, launching 28 homers, and his damage came disproportionately (.891 OPS) against lefties. He'd cost either $7 million and a low-level prospect or whatever the market bears, should the Rangers non-tender him, but he could be almost an everyday player, dividing his time between first base and DH. At 30,, he's not likely to plunge into decline in 2027, either. Some guys on this list can't say that. He would even come with an extra year of club control, in 2028.
- Paul Goldschmidt, Free Agent: Probably not a future Hall of Famer, Goldschmidt is as good as you can be without having that label slapped on you. He's had an unexpectedly graceful and valuable final act in his career, too, going to the Yankes and serving as a solid (though far from spectacular) lefty-mashing platoon guy. Even at the brink of turning 40, he's a plus defender at the cold corner. He'd be an excellent addition to the clubhouse, and offensively, he's more than the sum of his parts. As the Cubs learned when they signed Justin Turner, though, even great hitters are vulnerable to sudden collapse at this age. He'd cost a fair bit of money, the same way Turner did, but he's a better bet than Turner was.
- Josh Bell, Free Agent: The Twins signed Bell to a one-year deal to help them at first base last winter, and by the end of April, they had essentially given up on that idea and moved him to DH full-time. A switch-hitter with a balanced offensive skill set, Bell is just too huge a human to move nimbly around the base or get low quickly on grounders. He does everything fairly well at the plate, is a beloved teammate, and even gets a bit frisky on the bases at times, despite very little raw speed. He'd be more of a DH than a first baseman, but he could at least spell Busch as part of a larger role, and he's likely to come at a low price given what he can do at the plate.
- Royce Lewis, Minnesota Twins: Another Minnesota alumnus, Lewis is still under team control, but he's at least as likely to be non-tendered as Burger is. As recently as mid-May, he was a third baseman, but he has the right long-limbed build to be a plus first baseman, and he showed some flashes of that down the stretch. What he did not show, even after a reset in the minor leagues, was the consistent ability to hit the way a first baseman must. Lewis is also a former first overall pick with a high opinion of his own game and his future, so before acquiring him (in whatever fashion), the Cubs would need to make sure that he's on board with a reduced, complementary role.
- Ryan Mountcastle, Free Agent: There are big red flags with Mountcastle, whose profile at the plate is all-or-nothing as it gets. He has elite bat speed, but his swing is grooved and his approach is overly aggressive. He came up as a shortstop, and still shows some athleticism as a first baseman, so his defense won't hurt you. However, his bat can't carry more than a part-time role, and even then, you're betting on him getting back to mashing lefties consistently for the first time in multiple years.
- Eugenio Suárez, Free Agent: In the past, teams have profited nicely from buying low on Suárez, who's had a very up-and-down career but (as Cubs fans well know) can be a very dangerous righty slugger when he's on. Eventually, however, it becomes a bad bet to keep expecting him to recover from dips. Suárez has played first base only a few times over his long career, and might not be comfortable there at all, so he'd fit mostly as a DH. His value is very limited in that role, especially for the Cubs.
- Rhys Hoskins, Free Agent: Three players on this list are older than Hoskins, but none of them play older. A shadow of his Phillies self ever since the torn ACL that sidelined him for all of 2023, Hoskins has become a fairly desperate take-and-rake guy, trying to pull home runs right down the left-field line and taking as many walks as he can coerce from opposing pitchers. That's not a promising profile, especially as he projects to lose what little bat speed he has left in his mid-30s. He's heavy-footed at first base, too.
There aren't perfect solutions to the Cubs' problems available this winter. If they add one of the top three players from this list, they're likely to be pleased with the returns, but each would force a slightly different set of choices about their other positional needs. If they have to go lower than that, the risks rise quickly, and offensive decline becomes increasingly likely for what is a very veteran team. They can't afford that, so if they don't splurge for one of the top-tier names here, they had better have unexpectedly grand plans for their other lineup holes.
Want to play the role of Cubs general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Cubs roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now