Cubs Video
A year ago, neither Ben Malgeri nor Brett Callahan were even on most people's radar. FanGraphs ranked and gave reports on 34 Tigers prospects in 2023; 31 in 2024; 39 in 2025; and 47 in 2026. Malgeri and Callahan didn't show up on any of those lists. Malgeri, who will turn 27 in January, was an 18th-round pick in 2021 out of Northeastern. Callahan, 25, was a 13th-round pick in 2023 out of St. Joseph's. The Tigers have done a superb job scouting the northeastern corner of the country over the last handful of seasons, but not even they thought they had very much in either player.
In 2026, however, those two virtual unknowns combined for 240 big-league plate appearances. Malgeria was good; Callahan was bad. But each earned an unexpected opportunity, not just because the Tigers had a massively disappointing season, but because they played exceptionally well in the minors. Callahan had 416 plate appearances in 96 games at the top two levels in the minor leagues, batting .269/.365/.443. He hit 13 home runs there, and stole 29 bases in 35 tries. Most of that production dried up when he got to the bigs, but it was a clear step forward—and maybe more. A left-handed batter, Callahan is a plus runner with plus raw power. He'll need a slightly more disciplined approach than he showed in his stint in the majors, but it's now fair to at least dream on (and maybe even realistically hope for) a career as a mid-tier platoon outfielder.
The news on Malgeri might be even better. He's older, but he hit .296/.401/.496 in 297 plate appearances at Triple-A Toledo, earning a promotion to the majors. In 437 total tripe to the plate, he had 14 home runs and 13 stolen bases. He's a step faster than Callahan, and has a stronger arm, so he's a plus right fielder. His bat speed is below-average, but his approach is far more patient (and his feel for the barrel much better) than Callahan's. He bats right-handed, so he has to be a bit better to survive in a big role, but he just might clear that bar.
Though they might be a bit wary about sudden success from prospects without pedigree, most teams would feel very lucky to have players like Callahan and Malgeri, and it might be hard to pry them away. Detroit is in a unique position, though. They also promoted and installed a much higher-caliber outfield prospect late in the season, in 2023 first-round pick Max Clark. He'll be their regular center fielder in 2027, and All-Star slugger Riley Greene is poised to flank him in left field. They also traded for top prospect Zyhir Hope at the deadline, as the co-headliner of the Tarik Skubal deal.
In addition to those three, Detroit has slugger Kerry Carpenter, who (like Green) is still under team control for two more seasons. They have defensive whiz Parker Meadows, utility man Matt Vierling and the even more versatile Zach McKinstry. Like Carpenter, Wenceel Pérez had a tough 2026, but he's still a talented piece, too.
The Cubs are looking to add at least one outfielder this winter. Ideally, they'd add two, to replace the departing Ian Happ and Seiya Suzuki. Callahan and Malgeri, although low-profile, low-cost, low-ceiling pickups, would be under team control for six more seasons, and can be easily optioned to the minor leagues. Trading for either would keep all of Chicago's financial powder dry, and neither would cost them a top prospect. It would just be a matter of matching up properly.
Detroit might yet decide to roll with a modified platoon of Callahan and Malgeri at one outfield spot next year. In that case, they might instead trade one of Greene and Carpenter, in whom the Cubs would surely have interest. Greene would be a top-tier way to replace Happ, though he's set to make a healthy $9.3 million in 2027 and would also cost the team a handsome prospect package. Carpenter would be an upside play, with his raw power and history of mashing right-handed pitching balancing out a lack of plate discipline or defensive value.
One way or another, the Tigers are likely to move an outfielder, and they're likely to move them soon. Detroit's 40-man roster is full. The Cubs' has ample room for a player who can help them next season, even if it be in a somewhat limited role. The fit between the two is perfect, and Cubs executive Jed Hoyer and Tigers boss Scott Harris know each other as well as any two head baseball decision-makers in the game. It wouldn't be a surprise if the two of them got together on a deal early this week.
Want to play the role of Cubs general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Cubs roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now