Is this trade as good as I think it it?

[Ryno12]

I just traded:

 

Carl Crawford

Carlos Pena

 

for

 

BJ Upton

Aramis Ramirez

 

It's a roto league with R,HR, RBI, S, Ave, OPS

 

I had Miggy Cabrera at 3b, so I'm moving him to 1B, and Adam Dunn will go from 1B to Util.

[Clem Fandango]

I don't know. A lot of it depends on whether or not Crawford starts hitting the ball well again and whether or not Upton finds his power stroke again. Either way, Upton and Crawford should be good for at least 30 steals a piece. If they continue to be mediocre I'd say it's a wash. I think at this point Upton is a little better than Crawford and Aramis is a better overall hitter than Pena, though Pena will hit more HR and RBI.

 

I don't know. At this point I'd say it's a wash, but it's not a bad trade by any stretch of the imagination. Seems pretty fair to me

[Guest]

I'd make that trade in a heartbeat. I think you win this one in the long run.