Dunn for Rich Hill

[lloydo]

I have been offered Adam Dunn for Rich Hill.

 

Here are the details. Auto drafted 12 team Head to Head weekly standard 5 x 5

 

r hr rbi sb avg / w sv k era whip

 

Line up

 

c - Brian McCann

1b -Mark Teixeira

2b - Ian Kinsler

3b - Chone Figgins

ss - Jose Reyes

of - Carlos Beltran

of - Johnny Damon

of - Jason Bay

ut - Carlos Pena

 

Bench

Mike Lowell

Jermaine Dye

Dan Uggla

 

SP - Rich Hill

sp - Tim Lincecum

sp - Phil Hughes

sp - Oliver Perez

sp - Hiroki Kuroda

 

rp - JJ Putz

rp - Mat Capps

rp - Brandon Lyon

rp - Carlos Marmol

 

I really don't see where I need Dunn that much am I wrong? The guy offering me the trade first offered Chris Young (AZ - OF) and I passed on that one. I might be a little light in the HR department, but I should do ok most weeks. Any thoughts?

[UMFan83]

Are you sure another NSBB reader wasn't playing a joke on you?

[cheapseats]

PECOTA projects your offensive starters to hit .277 as a group which will likely put you near the bottom of your league in that category. Obviously neither Dunn nor Young (who I like more than Dunn) would help raise your team average.

 

Normally Young for Hill or Dunn for Hill would be a no-brainer, but such a deal doesn't really help your team much if it helps it at all.

[Tracer Bullet]

I agree w/ cheapseats. Can you strike a deal w/ another team to move an OF for another SP?