Obligatory 'Chime in on this trade proposal' thread

[10man]

trade proposal: Ian Snell (SP) for Elijah Dukes (OF)

 

It's a 16 team keeper league.

Snell is about 5th on my SP depth chart.

My current RF eligible players are Griffey and Huff.

It's a roto type scoring, btw.

[Mark_R]

Definitely no. Roto pitching is worth a lot and Dukes has had one good week. There's gotta be someone better on the waiver wire than that without giving up anybody.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

Who are your other pitchers?

[10man]

Who are your other pitchers?

Roy Oswalt

Ted Lilly

Nate Robertson

Anibal Sanchez

Orlando Hernandez

Josh Johnson (DL)

[Ding Dong Johnson]

I'd probably do it. Both are going to be really good, but pitchers' numbers sometimes suffer because of the crap team they're on.

[tkenm356]

Who are your other pitchers?

Roy Oswalt

Ted Lilly

Nate Robertson

Anibal Sanchez

Orlando Hernandez

Josh Johnson (DL)

 

My Ian Snell baseball man-crush will force me to say that Ian Snell is just as good a pitcher as El Duque, Sanchez, and Robertson, if not better. The guy is going to be sick, I don't care what anyone says.

 

But then again I'd only trade Snell if I were getting a Top 20 fantasy pick in exchange, that's how much I value him. So don't listen to me, I'm a Snell homer :)

[Mark_R]

Your pitching is mediocre at best. Do not trade Snell.