Gomes or Holliday?

[nilodnayr]

I need to deal one of them for a closer. Which one should I deal, and what level of closer should I be targeting? Its a 12 team 5 player keeper league. I'm thinking Gomes and Holliday are fairly similar except for BA, which Holliday will probably beat Gomes by about 30 points. I've been offered Chris Ray for Gomes, but I think I should be able to get better. The guy also has Jenks and Papelbon. Hes really really thin on OF. I'm thinking of countering with Gomes and Cameron for Papelbon. Thoughts?

[wolf stansson]

In a keeper league he would be absolutely [expletive] to give up Papelbon. I think you have a better shot at Jenks.

[nilodnayr]

In a keeper league he would be absolutely [expletive] to give up Papelbon. I think you have a better shot at Jenks.

 

Hes one of those guys that proposes ridiculous trades every day and it gets kinda annoying...I countered with Gomes, Cameron, Josh Johnson for Pap.