Now Grade the Trade

[ThePenguin11]

Team A:

 

K. Johjima

Z. Duke

A. Reyes

 

Team B:

 

R. Dempster

M. Clement

M. Lieberthal

 

13 Team Keeper league (max: 1 keeper in offseason)

Scoring is much like 5x5, and rewards heavily for HR, SB, Wins and Saves.

Edited April 13, 2006 by ThePenguin11

[Mark_R]

Team B is getting shafted.

[sherwood921]

Team A:

 

K. Johjima

Z. Duke

A. Reyes

 

Team B:

 

R. Dempster

M. Clement

M. Lieberthal

 

13 Team Keeper league (max: 1 keeper in offseason)

Scoring is much like 5x5, and rewards heavily for HR, SB, Wins and Saves.

 

Then what's the point of keepers if you only keep one? Or do you mean you can keep one of those 3?

[Mark_R]

Then what's the point of keepers if you only keep one? Or do you mean you can keep one of those 3?

 

I was kind of thinking the same thing. One keeper is useless.

[ThePenguin11]

You only get one keeper and it takes the place of your first round pick so only guys like Manny, Santana, Texeira, Arod get retained. Reyes and Duke weren't going to be keepers on my team regardless.

 

My team is team B. I gave up Johjima because I have Josh Willingham playing catcher. Reyes does me no good in the minors and will not be my keeper because I have King Felix as well. Here's my full roster after the trade:

 

Starter, Backup

C Josh Willingham, Mike Lieberthal

1B Justin Morneau, Mike Jacobs

2B Chase Utley, Ryan Freel

SS Michael Young

3B Scott Rolen, Pedro Feliz

OF Ichiro

OF Jim Edmonds

OF Aubrey Huff, Curtis Granderson, Luis Gonzalez

 

SP Carlos Zambrano

SP Felix Hernandez

SP Dan Haren, Matt Clement, Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, Noah Lowry, Dave Bush

 

RP Ryan Dempster, Tom Gordon, Eric Gagne (Inj.)

 

Johjima was dealt from depth, Duke has been eratic due to changes in his delivery by his inept pitching coach and Reyes can't help me right now. He would have been released to pick up my next waiver acquisition anyways. Does that change your opinion of my trade now?

[ThePenguin11]

Team A receives:

 

K. Johjima

Z. Duke

A. Reyes

 

Team B receives:

 

R. Dempster

M. Clement

M. Lieberthal

 

13 Team Keeper league (max: 1 keeper in offseason)

Scoring is much like 5x5, and rewards heavily for HR, SB, Wins and Saves.

 

Fixed to show who got what...