Prior or Buehrle?

[ChiCubsFan]

Which one would you rather have in a keeper league? Prior or Buehrle?

[Sweep The Leg Johnny]

Hrm, well I guess it depends on the rest of your keeper league team. Can you afford taking a risk in Prior? Without of a question, if Prior comes back healthy he'll be by far and away a better fantasy option. Heck, I think Prior 80-90% healthy is comparable to Buerhle.

 

If your team cannot afford a risk, I'd keep Buerhle. He's durable and you know what you're going to get. He'll get you 15-20 wins, a solid era, whip, and middle of the pack K numbers. He's not that exciting of a fantasy pitcher, but he's very steady. He's an ideal no.2/3 guy in a fantasy rotation.

[Diffusion]

Prior. Period. Especially in a keeper league.