Once upon a time, people were saying the same thing when a particular SS was picked up off the scrap heap. "Our SS's already suck," they once said, " what's the harm in giving Neifi Perez a shot." The harm is that if Womack hits superficially well (along the lines of an empty .280 BA), the Cubs won't resist bringing him back, possibly to a multi-year deal and possibly as a starter. Hendry and the Cubs are stupid that way. Nothing good can come of Tony Womack.