At this point, I'm saying yes to a one year incentive laced deal. The Edmonds/Johnson platoon is working too well to abandon it and hope (yet again) that Felix Pie can hit at this level. What if he doesn't hit (again) next year? Then you're in the same situation as this year, and probably aren't going to get as lucky with dumpster diving as they did with Edmonds. Pie isn't doing anything in AAA. He had a chance up here and didn't perform. So he got sent down, and isn't performing down there either. He shouldn't be rewarded with a promotion as a result. If Edmonds is cheap enough, sign him.