You can't count the "almost" misses without counting the "almost" catches though. You can't say he nearly threw picks without counting all the drops by the receivers, or blown routes. The raw numbers are the only facts on the table here. And they show a difference in performance from before the injury, to after. And that's fine about Tommie, I'm not debating that he's got injury issues...that's a no-brainer. All I was pointing out is that you didn't want to be quick on the trigger giving Orton a break due to injury...and then mentioned Tommie's injury issues later. Maybe it was a false comparison on my part, but I was simply pointing out that injuries do affect performance, as Tommie has shown...and that while you're concerned about a quick trigger...it's also not to be dismissed. That is fine but my comments on Tommie's injury issues was a tangent unrelated to any point I was making about Orton. I don't think we can expect a 100% Tommie for anywhere near a full season and even when he was "healthy" he was a non factor at times. Also I don't think Orton should have came back for the first Packers game. He should have gotten at least two if not three full weeks of rest to try and get that ankle healed up a little better. My main point I was attempting to make (perhaps poorly) about Orton was I saw some things in him that made me nervous before the injury. I wasn't trying to pin the Carolina loss on him, I understand Olsen fumbled the ball and other things happened but that game just stood out for me because of some of his bad throws and at that point in the season, I worried about how consistent Kyle would be. Now he did have some really solid games after that. After the Atlanta game I felt better about him overall. But I never reached a point of feeling completely sold on Kyle as The Guy. Then he got hurt. Kyle says the ankle bothered him, I'm not going to argue with Kyle. I'm not really trying to be hard headed about the whole thing, I just don't believe EVERY bad throw or bad game he had post-injury was directly a result of the ankle because some of the bad throws were just poor reads and I recalled him making similar throws before the injury. That is all. I really do hope the guy has a solid 2009 season. I have nothing against him.