He's trying to get his grit points back. Does arguing earn grit points? Can we get a ruling? If you are already gritty, yes. They multiply your current grit level, so if it is already negative (like when Alfonseca and Alou argued), it hurts. But it helps Theriot. I don't know if it gets less gritty than Antonio Alfonseca Losing a finger makes you gritty. Adding one is just pathetic. Okay, I'm a little embarassed at myself for contributing to the "Any Alfonseca reference must have a finger joke" mentalityi...