I don't like the idea of making roster decisions based on service time, and who is going to put up the biggest stink. I agree with your premise, but we don't really know what the Cubs told Miller to entice him to sign again, either. If they told him he would be starting or traded, then he has every right to be upset if they send him to the bullpen. Regardless, he should make the rotation because he wins the job with everything else being equal, not because of ancillary concerns. It really doesn't matter what they told him. We paid him 1 million to let him use the Cubs to rehab last season. We got nothing in return from that. If he can pitch well enough to win the spot, great. If Guz is better, Guz it should be.