It's not as good as you think. He's pitching stellar at home in a ballpark that fits his strengths, but he's not pitching so well on the road. At home: 9 G, 55 IP, 2.45 ERA, 45 H, 10 BB. On the Road: 8 G, 47.1 IP, 4.75 ERA, 61 H, 8 BB. I'm just not sold that he's that much better than what we have in the fourth and fifth spots. True, but he had one terrible start where he gave up 9 runs that really skews the road numbers. Take that out and his road ERA drops all the way to 3.15. And just because I know someone's thinking it, if you take out his best road start (since you're taking out his worst start) his ERA sits around 3.55. I'm still concerned that he's more a product of PETCO right now. We saw in his last year in Chicago he had a 4.63 ERA before going to the Dodgers. In that year, he was 5-0 to start the season and had a sparkling 1.35 ERA in April. As the weather warmed up, he had 5.94 ERA in May, 6.25 ERA in June and a 5.21 in July before we shipped him to the Dodgers. Last year, he was consistent in April and May with ERAs at 3.86 and 3.96 respectively. In June he had a 3.41 ERA before it ballooned to 5.57 in July. In 2005 he finished the year with a 4.24 ERA, 2006 it was 4.20 and 2007 it was 4.04 in PETCO (3.59 at home, 4.65 away). I think he's a pitcher that's going to give you an ERA in the mid four's. PETCO has helped hide his deficiencies. I like Maddux. He's probably one of my favorite all-time players, but I don't think he's much of an upgrade to the back-end of our rotation.