I can't say whether or not Dusty ruined those players. What can be said, is that he doesn't use the same logic on rookies as he does for veterans. For example, Hollandsworth struggled, but received a second chance. It was as if Dusty knew that hitting in the majors is tough and sometimes player have a bad streak. On the other hand, Dubois stuggled, but no worse than Hollandsworth did, yet wasn't even fit for pinch hitting much less a second chance. Dusty says he wanted to start Hollandsworth (0-5) today even though a lefty was on the mound, because sitting a week is a long time. However, do you actually think if we face six days of facing a right hander, Dusty will start Murton for the same reason? I doubt it. I hope I'm proved wrong, but it seems the logic is to protect and coddle the veterans, even if they are slumping, while a rookie better prove his worth right off the bat, because if he doesn't then he just doesn't have the skills to stick around.