That was a pretty weak attempt at reading what I wrote. I never said it was OK that he screwed up. My point is Barrett's defense isn't costing this team wins. Keep the team the same, and replace him with a real live catcher who is available, and this team is no better. There just isn't a catcher who is overall better than Barrett that you can get. All of you ripping him, and yes, you are ripping him, and making it quite clear you want him replaced, are ignoring the very important fact that you would have to replace him with a catcher that is available. And that's just not very likely to happen. What does "odds are, they still lose" mean? And if he is being ripped so what. I didn't know you couldn't rip a player on these boards. It means that Barrett is better than average overall as a catcher and anything that you can replace him with would make your team worse.