Mind explaining to me what kosuke did wrong there? Was it the horrible strike that he took for the first pitch or was it the pitch at his eyes he didn't actually swing at? Dude we get it the ump is inconsistent. He still swung at an awful pitch on 0-1 and he went on the last pitch. The second pitch wasn't a whole lot worse than the first, so one could assume he was swinging because if he didnt it would be called strike 2 anyway. Furthermore, I dont think he swung at that last strike. Even WITH that bad swing, however, he STILL should have walked. You can make a bad swing in an at bat and get away with it, he should have. What are you talking about? The second pitch ended up in the dirt and further away. Why don't you think he swung at the last one? He didn't argue, the home plate ump called it. He went. What was he going to do? Stand there and swear at him in japanese? Really? Because he's never stood there and disputed a pitch all year, right? He went and it really wasn't that close.