If you don't make the playoffs I call it an automatic F grade.
I thought they were a slightly better team than last year and yet didn't improve. Busch over Mancini, Imanaga in for Stroman (was hurt last year). The offense totally tanked from May to around the ASB and blew the season, along with Jed's crappy bullpen in the first half. They should have been right there in the wildcard hunt.
Adding Busch, Paredes, and Imanaga is solid though for years to come. Just MUCH too long of a rebuild. We got quality prospects for Rizzo, Baez, and Darvish but they were so young, and Ricketts should have overspent on the payroll to make up for it until they're ready, at least the last 2 seasons.
Last 2 seasons we're about 5 wins short of being a legit playoff team. We still burn too much money on fringe FA's. They sign Imanaga and then bring back Hendricks for 16.5m. Sign Swanson and then sign Mancini/Smyly/Barnhart on 2-year deals. Gotta be smarter and live the "value and efficiency" mantra on the smaller signings too.